Brookhaven Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining PORTERS on the lane $$ 304 reviews New American (631) 803-6067 19 Bellport LnBellport, NY 11713 Varney's Restaurant $$ 152 reviews Seafood, Burgers, Sandwiches (631) 286-9569 2109 Montauk HwyBrookhaven, NY 11719 Avino's Italian Table $$ 154 reviews Italian (631) 803-6416 108 S Country RdBellport, NY 11713 Painters' Restaurant $$ 348 reviews New American, Dance Clubs (631) 803-8593 416 S Country RdBrookhaven, NY 11719 The Bellport $$$ 84 reviews New American, Bars (631) 286-7550 159 S Country RdBellport, NY 11713 Peter's on the Green $ 30 reviews New American (631) 803-8440 40A S Country RdBellport, NY 11713 South Ocean Grill $$ 420 reviews Burgers, Seafood, Salad (631) 307-9999 567 S Ocean AvePatchogue, NY 11772 Brook House Pizza and Grill $ 15 reviews Pizza, Breakfast & Brunch, Sandwiches (631) 286-3450 2478 Montauk HwyBrookhaven, NY 11719 Smack N Chick $ 7 reviews Chicken Wings, Halal (631) 657-6242 800-6 Montauk HwyShirley, NY 11967 Chachama Grill $$$ 212 reviews New American (631) 758-7640 655-8 Montauk HwySwan Nursery Commons Cafe Castello $$ 42 reviews Italian (631) 803-8369 141 S Country RdBellport, NY 11713 Los Tres Hermanos $ 6 reviews Food Trucks, Mexican (631) 879-7247 Sunrise HwyStation Rd WhiskeyNeat $$ 90 reviews Whiskey Bars, American (631) 600-3434 124 E Main StPatchogue, NY 11772 La Buena Vida $$ 86 reviews Spanish (631) 909-1985 714 Montauk HwyMoriches, NY 11955 Okeno Sushi $$ 187 reviews Japanese, Sushi Bars (631) 668-8188 451 Glen DrShirley, NY 11967 Southpaw Brewing Company $$ 89 reviews Tacos, Pizza, Cocktail Bars (631) 504-6167 410 Princeton RdYaphank, NY 11980 Chara's Kitchen and Catering $$ 30 reviews Comfort Food, Pop-Up Restaurants, Soul Food (631) 355-5929 515 Atlantic AveBellport, NY 11713 Lola’s Southern Cuisine $ 77 reviews Southern (631) 730-8526 2717 A Rte 112Medford, NY 11763 Jimmy's Diner $ 117 reviews American, Breakfast & Brunch, Comfort Food (631) 281-5700 1535 Montauk HwyMastic, NY 11950 Mexican Grill 2000 $ 429 reviews Mexican (631) 207-6554 703 Rt 112Patchogue, NY 11772 T's Chicken and Fish $ 3 reviews Food Trucks, Sandwiches, Seafood (631) 530-6290 1700 Montauk HwyBellport, NY 11713 Mill House Inn $$ 58 reviews Coffee & Tea, American (631) 345-0361 284 Mill RdYaphank, NY 11980 Wings Cafe $ 32 reviews American, Breakfast & Brunch (631) 365-4282 135 Dawn DrShirley, NY 11967 La Jolla de Oro Restaurante $$ 12 reviews Salvadoran, Seafood, Breakfast & Brunch (631) 399-1131 234 William Floyd PkwyShirley, NY 11967 5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles $ 302 reviews Waffles, Sandwiches, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt (631) 438-0304 530 Medford AvePatchogue, NY 11772